Favorite M.I. so far? (Part II: 4/2002 - 12/2003)

Post by **Greg Stephens** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 6:23 pm

An earlier poll thread listed 10 M.I. comics for voting, and since we have 10 more since then (I left off "Proto the Pet" from the first poll due to some error on my part), it's time for another vote.

IronSpike · Post by **IronSpike** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 6:55 pm

"Somnivore." No contest.

Well... maybe "Uninformed Bob" runs a distant second. But my favorite's definitely "Somnivore." Super creepy.

Jimmy Ho · Post by **Jimmy Ho** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 7:49 pm

The main reason I voted for "Uninformed Bob" is that it is a successful example of exercice de style (in the Raymond Queneau/Oulipo meaning) in a comic form. As a secondary reason, I appreciated the "Newspaper funnies" parodical effect.
As I'm writing this, I'm still the only one, but who knows.

Surlyben · Post by **Surlyben** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 7:51 pm

Where is Robots Love to Dance? (edit due to html error...) I like the current one, and parallelogram, but they don't have robots. Mmm, dancing robots...

Post by **Scott McCloud** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 8:25 pm

Y'know, Greg. It might be kind of confusing with the topic heading.

Maybe we should change the thread title to Favorite *Recent* Improvs. (you don't really need "Proto" in there -- nobody, but NOBODY liked that one).

--Scott

buzzard · Post by **buzzard** » Fri Dec 05, 2003 11:34 pm

Actually, I liked Proto a lot. The art style was very playful. Or rather, there was a sense of playfulness to the process of choosing the art style, something we only see now and again (junk bar, when luna smiles). So I appreciated it on that front, at least.

Given the right choice of ten I'd pick Proto. It's certainly in my top five of this list.

Man, am I damning with faint praise here? Sorry. But really, it's no New Adventures of Abraham Lincoln.

Kris Lachowski · Post by **Kris Lachowski** » Sat Dec 06, 2003 12:56 am

buzzard wrote:Actually, I liked Proto a lot. The art style was very playful. Or rather, there was a sense of playfulness to the process of choosing the art style, something we only see now and again (junk bar, when luna smiles). So I appreciated it on that front, at least.

Given the right choice of ten I'd pick Proto. It's certainly in my top five of this list.

Man, am I damning with faint praise here? Sorry. But really, it's no New Adventures of Abraham Lincoln.

Darn you Buzzard!!! You stole everything I was going to say!

William G · Post by **William G** » Sat Dec 06, 2003 7:19 am

Evil That Men Forget to Do just has this wacky nonsensical quality that I enjoy.

Eric F Myers · Post by **Eric F Myers** » Sat Dec 06, 2003 11:38 am

My favorite comic on the site is Somnivore, just for the twisted beauty of it. Yet from an improv point of view I voted for The Evil That Men Forget To Do. It reminds me that we are reading true improvs, and just like in live t.v. (when the actors sometimes forget their lines or have no idea where the sketch is going) you never know what might happen. And when it ended with Scott on the ground clueless as were to take the story next brought home that point for me.

B.N.O.N. the Walrus had the same effect, I just liked Evil better because Scott was able to save the Walrus in the end.

Post by **Greg Stephens** » Mon Dec 08, 2003 5:34 pm

OK, I amended the topic title to show a date range. Not sure if that's more confusing or less. Thing is, "recent" is a relative term, and the M.I. comics featured in this poll span over a year's worth of time.

As to removing "Proto the Pet" from consideration, while it may not be anybody's favorite, does that mean it shouldn't even have the chance of being somebody's favorite? Where's the love for Proto?

gareis · Post by **gareis** » Mon Dec 08, 2003 6:29 pm

Greg Stephens wrote:Where's the love for Proto?

Left it in my other pants.

jazzsammich · Post by **jazzsammich** » Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:12 pm

you don't HAVE no other pants!

--jim

mecherath · Post by **mecherath** » Sat Dec 13, 2003 10:06 pm

Proto the Pet probably wasn't my favorite out of that list, but I just went back and read it, and I do like it. Its underdog status artificially boost its status enough that it earned my vote.

I like Meadow of the Damned too.

Zwol.org

Favorite M.I. so far? (Part II: 4/2002 - 12/2003)

What's your favorite M.I. of these 10?

Favorite M.I. so far? (Part II: 4/2002 - 12/2003)

evil

I Admit It